We restricted phones in Upper School. How’s it going?

Cell phone, smartphone in the hands of a man.

“It is okay to own a technology, what is not okay is to be owned by technology.”
—Abhijit Naskar

So, after a semester of upper school students not having access to their cellphones on campus during school hours, how’s it going?  I believe I can speak for many of us adults in saying that we appreciate the way students are interacting with one another in their classes and during lunch and free periods.  Their social interactions are not mediated by electronic devices, and it’s been delightful to see students engaged with their peers rather than staring into their phones eagerly anticipating the latest social media update. But what do students think about the change? And are we looking at changing our policy?

I wanted to take a step back and consider these questions after reading a December 19 New York Times op-ed essay by Ivy League Professor Colleen Kinder called “What Happened When My Yale Students Gave Up Their Phones for Four Weeks.”  In this piece, Kinder discusses the effects of her students traveling to France for a month and not having access to their phones.  As you may imagine, she sees tremendous benefits for her pupils as they are able to focus much more deeply on the current task, and they are able to play like the children they are.  Whether they are writing an essay without receiving constant notifications or sleeping much more deeply, the students see a remarkable change in their lives and their well-being. As she says wisely, “With the current generation, at least, what we as educators keep out is as important as what we put in.”  

So, with this article in mind, I asked two student leaders about the change in Keystone’s personal electronics policy, Senior Class President Breleigh and Student Body President Ricardo, also Class of 2026.  They both acknowledged that they were not happy when the letter announcing the new policy came out in August right before they were starting their senior year of high school.  They said it was a rough transition, and figured that the administration would eventually relent when we saw how challenging enforcement would be.  “Really, in our senior year, you choose to do this?” they said.  

Since August, though, they have found that it’s not been as hard as they initially thought.  Ricardo admitted that “it has been easier than I thought it would be.” Yes, it’s been a hassle at times, and the worst part is “we can’t take pictures to record when something fun happens.”  They have adapted to it, but “we look back at our freshmen, sophomore, and junior years, and we have a lot more pictures than we do this year.” As seniors, of course, they thought that they should have fewer restrictions than other grade levels. Breleigh also pointed out that “we use our phones for everything.” 

The two also recognized that the Outdoor Ed trip to Yosemite was different, and better, without phones than it would have been.  Instead of everyone immediately getting on their phones at night and isolating themselves, they hung out and told stories.  Breleigh shared how all the girls would gather in one room at the end of the day, laugh, and develop inside jokes.  Ricardo and Breleigh also related how people would play cards on the trip and get to know their classmates even better. 

 Ultimately, they have adapted to the policy, but they still wish at times that elements of the policy would be different.  Since they don’t wear watches, they have to check on their computers or ask others the time. But all in all, the absence of phones has enabled the class to become closer, particularly during their free periods when they hang out together in the “Slounge” (Senior Lounge.)  Their classmate El also acclimated by purchasing a first generation iPod Mini so he could listen to his music. In  retrospect, Breleigh and Ricardo are glad the change came during their senior year, since “I can tolerate it for one year.”  They do feel sorry for their younger schoolmates who have to live with the rule for all of high school. 

What about our youngest Upper Schoolers? Over lunch, ninth-graders Birdie, Isa, Nyla, and Valeria shared their opinions as new high schoolers.  

They concurred that it wasn’t that big of a change since they were not allowed to have their phones on them during middle school, and the longer the policy is in place, the easier the implementation will be due to younger students who will never have been able to have their phones.  Nyla said that she and her friends had already planned to not have their phones out during lunch or free periods so they could socialize with each other. 

Birdie, Isa, and Val did wonder if students were really learning how to use their phones responsibly under the new policy.  They felt that most Keystone students would not have their phones out during class since they need to focus, and the school should handle specific cases individually. They also believed that students should be able to use their phones during lunch and free periods.  The 9th graders also wondered if students not having access to their phones during the day made them even more eager than before to check them when school ended

Even when we didn’t agree, the conversation with these four 9th graders was delightful, and they were always respectful and civil while disagreeing.  I explained that the school is not looking to change the policy moving forward and they understood, even if they wished the decision was otherwise.

For an example of how young adults can gain control of their devices, look to a group of students at St. John’s College in Santa Fe. These “Johnnies,” as the students are known, opted to go off their devices for six days for a phone/tech “fast”.  They quickly learned how much they rely on their phones to be in touch with one another, and used some old-fashioned techniques such as leaving messages on centrally located chalkboards. They also acknowledged that they regained their ability to focus when they didn’t feel constantly distracted.  Unfortunately, they also realized that with even seemingly mundane activities such as doing laundry requiring QR codes, giving up phones permanently was not feasible.

I greatly enjoyed my lunches with Breleigh, Ricardo, Birdie, Isa, Nyla, and Val, and I appreciated hearing their insights and opinions.  

So are we going to change our phone/tech policies? Not for now. Keystone is committed to maintaining a device free campus during the school day for high school students, and for younger students at all times.  We believe that even with the inconvenience, the benefits of not having electronic devices on campus during the school day are well worth the side effects. 

Share it :

Newsletter

Signup our newsletter to find out what makes the Keystone experience unique.
By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Keystone School, 119 E. Craig Place, San Antonio, TX, 78212, US, http://www.keystoneschool.org. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact.

Latest Post

Categories

Brown Family Donates $3 million to Keystone School